Which is better, metal seat or soft seat ball valve?

When to Choose Metal Seat Valves vs. Soft Seat Ball Valves

Choosing a ball valve can be overwhelming due to the numerous options available. The construction materials, size, and design—whether it’s a one, two, or three-piece assembly, V-port, or a double block and bleed valve—play crucial roles in your selection. Equally important is determining the type of seat that best meets your needs.

Click here for additional information.

To make an informed decision regarding the valve seat, understanding your process conditions is essential. Consider whether the fluid is corrosive, contains abrasive materials, operates under high temperatures or pressures, or requires a bubble-tight shut-off. Once you assess these factors, the choice becomes clearer.

Soft Seated Ball Valves

Soft seats are typically crafted from thermoplastic materials such as PTFE, which are ideal for applications where chemical compatibility and tight sealing are critical. However, they are not suitable for fluids that are dirty or abrasive, as these conditions can lead to degradation and leakage of the valve.

Metal Seated Ball Valves

Metal seated valves have a significant advantage over their soft seated counterparts due to their capability to withstand extreme temperatures and harsh operating conditions. These valves can handle severe flashing, hydraulic shock, abrasive fluids, and temperatures that can reach or exceed 1,000°F. Metal seats are an excellent choice for applications prone to high erosion or corrosion.

Additionally, metal seats can be enhanced with hard coatings, such as ultrasonic spray coating, satellite hard facing, chromium carbide, or tungsten carbide, which further increases their durability.

Which is Suitable for Your Process?

When evaluating the initial purchase price, metal seated ball valves tend to be more expensive than soft seated valves. However, it's essential to factor in total cost considerations, including potential downtime and the expenses related to replacing soft seated valves. In many scenarios, total ownership costs may be more favorable for metal seated options.

Identifying your specific process conditions is crucial in determining the ideal seat for your application. If uncertainty persists, consulting with an engineer experienced in valve selection is recommended to discover the most suitable solution.

Need assistance with selecting a suitable seat for your application? We’re here to help! We offer technical support regarding valves for businesses and municipalities across the United States.

Metal Seated Ball Valve vs. Soft Seated Valves

Why might a metal seated ball valve be a preferable choice over a soft seated one? This decision depends on your specific process and applications. Generally, metal seated valves are more suitable for severe service applications. Although the initial cost is higher, they tend to provide a longer lifespan, reducing the need for frequent replacements of soft seat variants and minimizing non-productive downtime due to seat leaks in harsh environments.

Understanding the Differences: Metal Seated vs. Soft Seated

While both soft and metal seated ball valves function similarly, sealing occurs when the ball contacts the seat. Soft seated valves typically utilize thermoplastics like PTFE or NBR, while metal seated valves are made from materials like stainless steel and nickel alloys.

For further details, visit YIYUAN. Generally, soft seated valves may have a higher leakage class, often ensuring a bubble-tight shut-off. On the other hand, metal seated valves provide high-performance seals, typically achieving ANSI class IV or V. In the case of class IV, less than 0.01% of the total valve capacity leaks during pressure tests when fully open.

Choosing Metal Seated Options

How do you decide between metal seated and soft seated ball valves? Begin with a thorough understanding of your process and conditions, such as fluid temperatures, abrasiveness, corrosiveness, and pressure levels. For many heavy-duty industrial applications, metal seated ball valves are often the better option due to their robustness against extreme conditions.

Metal seated isolation valves can cater to a diverse range of severe service applications, including:

• High temperatures

• Cryogenic temperatures

• Abrasive environments

• Dirty fluids

• Corrosive substances

• Elevated pressures

Your selection of a metal seated ball valve will also depend on the fluid you need to isolate. This will impact the seat material, ball mount type, and the hard coating employed. For example, trunnion mounted balls are preferable for high-pressure situations, while floating ball mounted valves are suitable for low to medium pressure processes. Tungsten carbide hard coatings are rated for use at temperatures below 302°F, whereas chrome carbide or other coatings are better for higher temperatures.

Additionally, you must choose between cast and forged ball valves. Forged options generally exhibit superior resistance to high pressures and temperatures, while cast valves often provide quicker turnaround times and cost-effectiveness.

For severe service valves, reach out to our team at Copeland Valve & Coating Technologies. We have a longstanding history of manufacturing ball valves and can meet your custom and standard valve requirements. Our products are crafted in the U.S.A. to ensure unparalleled quality control and swift delivery. Contact us today to request a quote for our high-performance valves.

If you want to learn more about Hard-Sealing Valve Ball And Seat, don’t hesitate to contact us for expert consultation!